Transcranial sonography for diagnosis of Parkinson's disease
© Mehnert et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2010
Received: 5 August 2009
Accepted: 21 January 2010
Published: 21 January 2010
In idiopathic Parkinson's disease (IPD) transcranial sonography (TCS) represents an alternative diagnostic method to verify clinical diagnosis. Although the phenomenon of an increased echogenicity of the Substantia nigra (SN) is well known this method is still not widly used in the diagnostic workup. Until now reliability of this method is still a matter of debate, partly because data only existed from a few laboratories using the same ultrasound machine. Therefore our study was conducted to test the reliability of this method by using a different ultrasound device and examining a large population of control and IPD subjects by two examiners to calculate interobserver reliability.
In this study echogenicity of SN was examined in 199 IPD patients and 201 control subjects. All individuals underwent a neurological assessment including Perdue pegboard test and Webster gait test. Using a Sonos 5500 ultrasound device area of SN was measured, echogenicity of raphe, red nuclei, thalamus, caudate and lenticular nuclei, width of third and lateral ventricle were documented.
We found a highly characteristic enlargement of the SN echogenic signal in IPD. The cut-off value for the SN area was established using a ROC curve with a sensitivity of 95% corresponding to an area of SN of 0.2 cm2 and was found to be equivalent to the cut-off values of other studies using different ultrasound devices.
Our study shows that TCS is a reliable and highly sensitive tool for differentiation of IPD patients from individuals without CNS disorders.
Diagnosis of idiopathic Parkinson's disease (IPD) is usually based on clinical criteria. However, in some cases differential diagnosis especially in early stages of the disease might be difficult. Single photon emission tomography (SPECT) or positron emission tomography (PET) may pose problems in terms of costs, availability and exposure to radiation. In recent years, transcranial B-mode sonography (TCS) appeared as new diagnostic modality to support the clinical diagnosis of IPD using a different physical principle of imaging. Since the first and pathbreaking description of an increased echogenicity of the substancia nigra (SN) in IPD by Becker et al in 1995, these findings were corroborated by several studies since then [1–9]. However, TCS is not a widespread diagnostic method, because patient and control cohorts so far were small and diagnostic thresholds appeared to be dependent on the technology used. In fact, reference values in large patient groups so far have been only established for Siemens Sonoline Elegra (Siemens, Erlangen, Germany) and lately for Aplio (Toshiba Medicals, Japan) [2, 3, 8, 10]. We used a different ultrasound device, SONOS 5500, Philips, Netherlands, but followed an established examination protocol. Until now studies using the same ultrasound machine only involved small subject groups. Vlaar et al examined 82 patients with unclassified Parkinsonian syndromes using a SONOS 5500 and reported a sensitivity of 50% to differentiate IPD patients from patients without nigrostriatal degeneration or atypical Parkinsonian syndromes (specificity 82% and 43% respectively). Remarkably a positive qualitative scoring of the SN echogenicity always corresponded to a SN area larger than 0.2 cm2 . Hagenah et al reported a sensitivity of 0.71 and a specificity of 0.58 at a cut-off of 0.27 cm2 SN area examining 58 individuals, 21 controls, 24 with clinically definite PD and 13 unaffected Parkin gene carriers . In another study an increased area of SN in a group of 20 family members with a PINK1 mutation and 15 relatives of patients with sporadic PD compared to 18 healthy subjects was documented . The current study examines the echogenicity of the SN in IPD in a very large cohort of patients and controls. Aim of this study was to clarify the influence of age or life circumstances on the echogenicity of SN in healthy and IPD individuals. A further aim was to establish reference values beyond the most often used ultrasound technology and to provide data on the interobserver reliability of the method. This ultrasound technique has often been criticized as subjective, as observer and device dependent.
Descriptive statistics are given as median and lower (25th percentile) and upper (75th percentile) quartile. Correlation analysis was performed by Spearman's rank correlation. For group comparison an unpaired non-parametric data Mann- Whitney-test and for non-parametric data Kruskal-Wallis Test was used. A correction for multiple comparisons was performed where appropriate. For comparison between IPD and NCD group the combined measurements of left and right side were used. The cut-off value was established by Receiver Operating Characteristics (ROC) analysis. Interobserver reliability was calculated as mean ± SD and variation coefficient was estimated.
In the IPD group transcranial ultrasound could be performed in 183 individuals. 183 of 199 patients (92%) had a sufficient acoustic bone window at least on one side and 15 of these patients only on one side. Their median age was 66 (62;71) years, 24 had a predominant tremor form, 80 akinetic-rigid form and 79 equivalent form. In the NCD group examination was possible unilaterally in all individuals, whereas, bilateral investigation was not possible in 6 of 201 individuals (3%). The median age of NCD individuals was 49 (32;64) years.
In the IPD group median area of the SN was 0.3 cm2 (0.25;0.37) on the left side and 0.29 cm2 (0.25;0.36) on the right side. In the NCD group median area of SN on left side was 0.12 cm2 (0.1;0.15), on the right side 0.12 cm2 (0.09;0.15). The difference of SN sizes between IPD patients and NCD healthy individuals proofed to be highly significant (p < 0.001).
The measurement of SN was found to be adequately reproducible considering the small size of the structure; variation between two observers was small (variation coefficient 0.085). The difference was 0.018 cm2 ± 0.015 cm2, the range 0.0 cm2 to 0.12 cm2. Evaluation concerning group membership applying the cut-off of 0,2 cm2 differed only in 2 NCD and 3 IPD subjects.
The cut-off value for the SN area was established using a Receiver Operating Characteristics (ROC) curve with a sensitivity (true positive rate) of 95%. This corresponded to an area of SN of 0.2 cm2 (AUC 0.989). At this cut-off value specificity in our cohort was 96%.
Clinical and TCS data of NCD group
Number of NCD individuals
Prevalence of SN >0,2 cm2, N; in %
0.13 (0.07; 0.15)
0.11 (0.06; 0.13)
0.13 (0.07; 0.16)
0.13 (0.07; 0.16)
0.14 (0.05; 0.15)
In NCD group SN size increased with age (Spearman Rho = 0.17, p < 0.02), but individuals with SN size >0,2 cm2 did not significantly differ in age from individuals with SN size <0,2 cm2 (Mann-Whitney-U p > 0.5). In NCD group individuals SN size was larger with decreasing hand motor function measured in Pegboard test (Spearman Rho -0.23, p = 0.01), but no significant difference of motor function was found between healthy subjects with normal or increased SN size (Mann-Whitney-U p > 0.1). No correlation was found with Webster's gait test (Spearman Rho 0.13, p > 0.08).
Clinical and TCS data of IPD group
Number of IPD individuals
Prevalence of SN <= 0,2 cm2, N; in %
0.28 (0.24; 0.39)
0.31 (0.28; 0.33)
0.30 (0.26; 0.36)
0.29 (0.25; 0.38)
Clinical data of IPD patients grouped according to SN size in TCS
Whole IPD group* (n = 183)
IPD patients SN <= 0.2 cm2* (n = 9)
IPD patients SN>0.2 cm2* (n = 174)
Age at disease onset, y
Disease duration, months
Duration since L-Dopa start, y
5 (3; 8)
L-Dopa equivalent dose, mg
UPDRS III score
Pegboard test score
Webster gait test
Qualitative assessment of echogenicity of brainstem raphe, red nucleus, thalamus, caudate and lenticular nuclei in NCD and IPD group
NCD group (n = 201)
IPD group (n = 183)
grade 1:n = 23
grade 2:n = 176
grade 1:n = 30
grade 2:n = 130
grade 1:n = 44
grade 2:n = 150
grade 1:n = 44
grade 2:n = 154
grade 1:n = 47
grade 2:n = 113
grade 1:n = 49
grade 2:n = 109
grade 1:n = 198
grade 2,3:n = 0
grade 1:n = 198
grade 2,3:n = 0
grade 1:n = 157
grade 2,3:n = 0
grade 1:n = 156
grade 2:n = 1
grade 3:n = 0
grade 1:n = 194
grade 2:n = 3
grade 1:n = 194
grade 2:n = 4
grade 1:n = 155
grade 2:n = 13
grade 3:n = 1
grade 1:n = 150
grade 2:n = 19
grade 3:n = 3
grade 1:n = 197
grade 2,3:n = 1
grade 1:n = 196
grade 2:n = 2
grade 3:n = 0
grade 1:n = 162
grade 2:n = 3
grade 3:n = 2
grade 1:n = 166
grade 2:n = 4
grade 3:n = 0
Transcranial sonography is a valuable method for differentiation of IPD patients from healthy individuals. We could demonstrate a highly characteristic enlargement of SN echogenic signal in patients with IPD. Our results correspond to the findings of other studies. Due to the large group of patients and control subjects studied our results emphasize the importance of this diagnostic tool. The SN echogenic sizes found in our large and homogeneous cohort of individuals without CNS disorder ranging in age from 20 to 79 years correspond to the results in smaller studies reporting a median SN sizes of 0.14 cm2 for healthy subjects aged 50 to 59 years, 0.10 cm2 for subjects 60 to 69 years, and 0.15 cm2 for subjects 70 to 79 years and median SN sizes for patients with nonparkinsonian cerebral disorders of 0.13 cm2, although different ultrasound equipment was used [2, 8]. Our IPD patients showed a median SN echogenic size of 0.29 cm2. This is slightly higher than the reported median SN echogenic size of IPD patients of 0.25 cm2 using Siemens ultrasound devices [2, 8].
We set our cut-off value at a sensitivity of 95%. Interestingly, our cut-off value turned out to be equivalent to the cut-off values of other studies, despite differences in the median values using different ultrasound equipment [2, 8]. It has to be admitted that in the study of Hagenah et al using the same device SONOS 5500 a lower sensitivity and specificity at a differing cut off of 0,27 cm2 was reported, probably due to the small sample size or due to the different patient sample (Parkin mutation carriers) . Unfortunately formal studies comparing different devices in the same cohort are still lacking. Nevertheless based on our results and considering that in other studies using the same or different ultrasound devices similar scoring criteria concerning SN area were established, the hypothesis that the sonographic method is not substantially influenced by the ultrasound device seems acceptable [11, 2, 8]. The validity of the scoring criteria, independent of the devices used, is of paramount importance, since this is the basis to advocate TCS as the method of choice in the diagnostic workup of movement disorders.
The dependence of this ultrasound technique on experience and a relative subjectivity of results is an often discussed matter of critique. Regarding the low interobserver variance in our study these arguments might be softend. As documented through our data a good reproducibility can be achieved. Our study design did not allow a blinding towards group membership of individuals included in this study and this may have influenced the results of the study. Given the clinical aspect of IPD patients a sufficient blinding of experienced examiners is almost impossible or would at least require an enormous effort as reported by Prestel et al.  We have to admit that our results might be influenced by the age difference of the groups and the lack of a sufficient blinding, so the specificity might be slightly overestimated.
In our study we found a rate of 6.5% of NCD individuals with at least unilaterally increased SN size. A similar rate of about 9% has been reported before [1, 2]. Despite the frequency of increased SN size in NCD in our study is higher than the estimated risk of about 0.1% of IPD in the general population it is thought to reflect a vulnerability for developing nigrostriatal disorders .
A slight increase of SN size revealed with increasing age and we found worse hand motor function (Pegboard test) correlating with larger SN size. Previously, it has been demonstrated that elderly subjects without prediagnosed extrapyramidal disorder but with increased SN size developed more often signs of motor retardation .
Previous studies showed no change of SN sizes in the course of the disease and according to our results no correlation with parameters of disease severity i.e. Hoehn & Yahr stages, UPDRS, Webster-, Pegboard-Test. It is assumed that SN hyperechogenicity reflects an increased amount of iron in the SN, bound to proteins other than ferritin [1, 2, 9]. It is regarded as a trait marker pointing to a predisposition for the disease not a severitiy marker reflecting proceeding nigral cell loss . Our results show that neither sonographic classification of raphe, thalamus, lenticular or caudate nuclei nor measurement of ventricles could serve as suitable parameters to discriminate healthy individuals from IPD patients. Recent studies showed that these parameters are of paramount importance to distinguish atypical Parkinsonian syndromes from IPD .
Our study shows that TCS is a reliable and highly sensitive tool for differentiation of IPD patients from individuals without CNS disorders. In consideration of other studies our results point to a relative independence of the SN scoring parameters on the ultrasound equipment.
Our study focused on clinicaly diagnosed IPD and did not include atypical Parkinsonian syndromes, this may be seen as a shortcoming. A possible bias influencing our results might be the age difference of the two groups though the investigators were not sufficiently blinded.
We thank all patients and healthy volunteers for consenting to take part in this study and Dr. M. Oechsner for his contribution in the recruitment of patients.
- Becker G, Seufert J, Bogdahn U, Reichmann H, Reiners K: Degeneration of substantia nigra in chronic Parkinson's disease visualized by transcranial color-coded real-time sonography. Neurology. 1995, 45: 182-184.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Berg D, Becker G, Zeiler B, Tucha O, Hofmann E, Preier M, Benz P, Jost W, Reiners K, Lange KW: Vulnerability of the nigrostriatal system as detected by transcranial ultrasound. Neurology. 1999, 53: 1026-1031.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Berg D, Siefker C, Ruprecht-Dorfler P, Becker G: Relationship of substantia nigra echogenicity and motor function in elderly subjects. Neurology. 2001, 56: 13-17.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Berg D, Roggendorf W, Schroder U, et al: Echogenicity of the substantia nigra: association with increased iron content and marker for susceptibility to nigrostriatal injury. Arch Neurol. 2002, 56: 999-1005. 10.1001/archneur.59.6.999.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Jabs BE, Berg D, Merschdorf U, Bartsch AJ, Pfuhlmann B: Differences in substantia nigra echogenicity of nosological subtypes within the schizophrenic spectrum. A preliminary transcranial ultrasound study. Neuropsychobiology. 2001, 44 (4): 183-186. 10.1159/000054940.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Postert T, Lack B, Kuhn W, et al: Basal ganglia alterations and brain atrophy in Huntington's disease depicted by transcranial real time sonography. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1999, 67: 457-462. 10.1136/jnnp.67.4.457.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Ruprecht-Dörfler P, Berg D, Tucha O, Benz P, Meier-Meitinger M, Alders GL, Lange KW, Becker G: Echogenicity of the substantia nigra in relatives of patients with sporadic Parkinson's disease. Neuroimage. 2003, 18 (2): 416-422. 10.1016/S1053-8119(02)00035-6.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Walter U, Wittstock M, Benecke R, Dressler D: Substantia nigra echogenicity is normal in non-extrapyramidal cerebral disorders but increased in Parkinson's disease. J Neural Transm. 2002, 109: 191-196. 10.1007/s007020200015.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Walter U, Niehaus L, Probst T, Benecke R, Meyer BU, Dressler D: Brain parenchyma sonography discriminates Parkinson's disease and atypical parkinsonian syndromes. Neurology. 2003, 60 (1): 74-77.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Okawa M, Miwa H, Kajimoto Y, Hama K, Morita S, Nakanishi I, Kondo T: Transcranial sonography of substantia nigra in Japanese patients with Parkinson's disease or atypical Parkinsonism: clinical potential and limitations. Intern Med. 2007, 46 (18): 1527-31. 10.2169/internalmedicine.46.0271.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Vlaar AM, de Nijs T, van Kroonenburgh MJ, Mess WH, Winogrodzka A, Tromp SC, Weber WE: The predictive value of transcranial duplex sonography for the clinical diagnosis in undiagnosed parkinsonian syndromes: comparison with SPECT scans. BMC Neurol. 2008, 8: 42-10.1186/1471-2377-8-42.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Hagenah J M, König I R, Becker B, Hilker R, Kasten M, Hedrich K, Pramstaller P P, Klein C, Seidel G: Substantia nigra hyperechogenicity correlates with clinical status and number of Parkin mutated alleles. J Neurol. 2007, 254: 1407-1413. 10.1007/s00415-007-0567-y.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hagenah J M, Becker B, Bruggemann N, Djarmati A, Lohmann K, Sprenger A, Klein C, Seidel G: Transcranial sonography findings in a large family with homozygous and heterozygous PINK1 mutations. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2008, 79: 1071-1074. 10.1136/jnnp.2007.142174.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hughes AJ, Daniel SE, Kilford L, Lees AJ: Accuracy of clinical diagnosis of idiopathic Parkinson's disease: a clinico-pathological study of 100 cases. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1992, 55 (3): 181-184. 10.1136/jnnp.55.3.181.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Fahn S, Elton RL, Members of the UPDRS Development Committee: The Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale. Recent developments in Parkinson's disease. Edited by: Fahn S, Marsden CD, Calne DB, Goldstein M. 1987, Florham Park, NJ: Macmillan Health Care Information, 2: 153-163. 293-304.Google Scholar
- Webster DD: Critical analysis of the disability in Parkinson's disease. Mod Treat. 1968, 5: 257-282.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Vingerhoets FJ, Schulzer M, Calne DB, Snow BJ: Which clinical sign of Parkinson's disease best refelcts the nigrostriatal lesion?. Ann Neurol. 1997, 41 (1): 58-64. 10.1002/ana.410410111.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Maschke M, Gomez CM, Tuite PJ, et al: Dysfunction of the basal ganglia, but not the cerebellum, impairs kinaesthesia. Brain. 2003, 126: 2312-22. 10.1093/brain/awg230.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hobson DE, Lang AE, Martin WR, et al: Excessive daytime sleepiness ans sudden onset sleep in Parkinson disease: a survey by the Canadian Movement Disorders Group. JAMA. 2002, 287: 455-63. 10.1001/jama.287.4.455.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Parkin SG, Gregory RP, Scott R, et al: Unilateral and bilateral palidotomy for idiopathic Parkinson's disease: a case series of 115 paients. Mov Disord. 2002, 17: 682-92. 10.1002/mds.10186.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Walter U, Behnke S, Eyding J, Niehaus L, Postert T, Seidel G, Berg D: Transcranial brain parenchyma sonography in movement disorders: state of the art. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2007, 33 (1): 15-25. 10.1016/j.ultrasmedbio.2006.07.021.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Prestel J, Schweitzer KJ, Hofer A, Gasser T, Berg D: Predictive value of transcranial sonography in the diagnosis of Parkinson's disease. Mov Dis. 2006, 21 (10): 1763-1765. 10.1002/mds.21054.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2377/10/9/prepub
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.