Skip to main content

Table 2 Domain scores from AGREE II evaluation

From: Guidelines for dementia or Parkinson’s disease with depression or anxiety: a systematic review

Guideline (year)

Domain 1 score scope & purpose

Domain 2 score stakeholder involvement

Domain 3 score rigour of development

Domain 4 score clarity of presentation

Domain 5 score applicability

Domain 6 score editorial independence

Parkinson’s Disease

 Zesiewicz et al. (2010) [35]

56.9

29.2

64.6

72.2

17.7

79.2

 SIGN (2010)a [37]

80.6

80.6

72.9

91.7

72.9

22.9

 Grimes et al. (2012)c [34]

70.8

95.8

90.6

87.5

60.4

58.3

 Berardelli et al. (2013) [38]

72.2

19.4

47.9

86.1

12.5

6.3

 Ferreira et al. (2013) [40]

47.2

15.3

43.2

66.7

6.25

20.8

Dementia

 NICE (2011)b [41]

83.3

81.9

86.5

87.5

64.6

47.9

 Hort et al. (2010) [47]

58.3

38.9

54.2

66.7

25.0

62.5

 AIAQS (2010) [42]

87.5

69.4

73.4

84.7

57.3

79.2

 Ihl et al. (2011) [44]

68.1

38.9

57.8

48.6

19.8

64.6

 CRCD (2011) [43]

86.1

62.5

74.5

81.9

51.0

54.2

 O’Brien et al (2011) [60]

59.7

63.9

46.4

76.4

20.8

68.8

 Sorbi et al. (2012) [45]

68.1

38.9

53.7

65.3

26.0

62.5

 Gauthier et al (2012)d [50]

73.6

70.8

70.8

87.5

50.0

79.2

Mental Health

 Gelenberg et al. (2010) [39]

68.1

41.7

61.5

66.7

32.3

60.4

 Dua et al. (2011) [49]

70.8

41.7

66.7

84.7

68.7

93.8

 Avalia-T (2012) [46]

88.9

70.8

79.2

75.0

49.0

60.4

 Mitchell et al. (2013) [48]

86.1

66.7

75.0

80.6

71.9

85.4

Average Domain Score (SD)

72.1 (12.1)

54.5 (23.3)

65.8 (13.9)

77.0 (11.4)

41.5 (22.6)

59.2 (23.7)

  1. SD Standard Deviation
  2. a Includes Grosset et al. [54]
  3. b Originally created in 2007 and updated in 2011
  4. c Includes Patel et al. [61]
  5. d Includes Moore et al. [62], Herrman et al. [63]