Skip to main content

Table 3 Quality score for selected studies

From: A critical review of manual therapy use for headache disorders: prevalence, profiles, motivations, communication and self-reported effectiveness

Dimensions of Quality Assessment

Authors/Year

Methodology

Participant characteristics

Reporting of MT use

Total score

Ailliet et al, 2010 [65]

A, B, C

F, H

I

6

Bigal et al, 2008 [19]

A, B, C, D

E, F, G, H

 

8

Brown et al, 2013 [69]

A, B, C, D

F, H

 

6

Brown et al, 2014 [61]

A, B, C, D

F, G, H

I

8

Cherkin et al, 2002 [62]

A, B, C, D

F, G

I

7

Cooke et al, 2010 [49]

A, B, D

E, F,

 

5

Coulter et al, 2002 [66]

A, B, D

F, G, H

 

6

French et al, 2013 [64]

A, B, D

F, G, H

I

7

Gaul et al, 2009 [70]

A, B, D

E, F, G, H

I

8

Gaul et al, 2011 [72]

A, B, D

E, F, H

I

7

Gaumer G, 2006 [56]

A, B, D

F, H

 

5

Goksel et al, 2014 [73]

A, B, D

E, F, H

I

7

Hartvigsen el al, 2003 [68]

A, B, C, D

  

4

Kristofferson et al, 2012 [20]

A, B,

E, F, G

I

6

Kristoffersen et al, 2013 [79]

A, B, D

E, F,

I

6

Lambert et al, 2010 [77]

A, D

F, G, H

I

6

Lyngberg et al, 2005 [1, 52]

A, B, C, D

E, F

 

6

Malone et al, 2015 [71]

B, C, D

F,

 

4

Ossendorf et al, 2009 [60]

A, B, C, D

F, H

I

7

Rossi et al, 2005 [53]

A, B, D

E, F, H,

I

7

Rossi et al, 2006 [58]

A, B, D, E, F, H

 

I

7

Rossi et al, 2008 [59]

A, B, C, D

E, F, H

 

7

Rubinstein et al, 2000 [67]

A, B, C, D

F, H

 

6

Sanderson et al, 2013 [21]

A, B, C, D

E, F, G, H

 

8

S von Peter et al, 2002 [78]

C, D

E, F, G, H

I

7

Vukovic et al, 2010 [48]

A, B, C, D

E, F,

 

6

Wells et al, 2010 [51]

A, B, D

F, G, H

 

6

Wells et al, 2011 [50]

A, B, D

F, G, H

I

7

Xue et al, 2008 [55]

A, B, D

F, G, H

 

6

  1. Key: A-Sampling reported, B-Sample size >100, C-Response rate >75%, D-Low recall bias, E-Classification of headache type, F-Age and sex, G-Ethnicity, H-Socioeconomic status Scoring: 1-4 poor quality, 5-6 low quality, 7-8 moderate quality, 9-10 high quality