Skip to main content

Table 2 Consensus ACROBAT-NRSI judgments between two reviewers by domain of bias

From: Is traumatic brain injury a risk factor for neurodegeneration? A meta-analysis of population-based studies

Component Study Domain Overall RoB Bias
Bias Due to Judgment Confounding Bias in Selection of Participants Bias in Measurement of Interventions Bias Due to Departures from Intended Interventions Bias in Measurement of Outcomes Bias in Selection of Reported Results Bias Due to Missing Data
Mehta KM, et al. [20] moderate moderate low low low low low moderate
Luukinen H, et al. [21] low low low low low low low low
Sundström A, [22] low low low low low low low low
Luukinen H, et al. [23] low low low low low low low low
Wang HK, [25] low moderate low low moderate low low low
Gardner RC, et al. [26] low moderate low low moderate low low low
Nordström P, et al. [27] low moderate low low moderate low low low
Abner EL, et al. [28] low moderate low low moderate low low low
Rasmusson DX, et al. [29] low low low low low low low low
Nemetz PN, et al. [30] low moderate low low moderate low low low
Barnes DE, et al. [31] low moderate low low moderate low low low
Spangenberg S, et al. [32] low low low low low low low low
Lee PC, et al. [33] low low low low low low low low
Taylor KM, et al. [34] low low low low low low low low
Gardner RC, et al. [35] low moderate low low moderate low low low
Kalkonde YV, [36] low low low low low low low low
Wang HK, et al. [5] low moderate low low moderate low low low
Chen H, et al. [37] low low low low low low low low