Skip to main content

Table 1 Summary of study characteristics of the included studies

From: A systematic review of cytokines in chronic fatigue syndrome/myalgic encephalomyelitis/systemic exertion intolerance disease (CFS/ME/SEID)

Observational Studies

Sample Size

Author

Year

Study Design

Dx

Cytokine Origin

Cytokine Analysis

Country

CFS/ME

HC

Fletcher, et al. [20]

2009

Case Control

Fukuda

Serum

ELISA

U.S.A.

40

59

Hardcastle, et al. [21]

2015

Case Control

Fukuda

Serum

MBAA

Australia

41

22

Hornig, et al. [22]

2016

Case Control

Fukuda and CCC

CSF

MBAA

U.S.A.

32

19

Kennedy, et al. [23]

2004

Case Control

Fukuda

Serum

ELISA

United Kingdom

47

34

Landi, et al. [24]

2016

Case Control

Fukuda and/or CCC

Serum

ELISA

U.S.A.

100

79

Montoya J, et al. [25]

2017

Case Control

Fukuda

Serum

MBAA

U.S.A.

186

388

Nakamura, et al. [26]

2010

Case Control

Fukuda

Serum

MBAA

U.S.A.

11

24

Nas K, et al. [27]

2011

Case Control

ICC

Serum

MBAA

Turkey

25

20

Natelson, et al. [28]

2005

Case Control

Fukuda

CSF

MBAA

U.S.A.

44

13

Neu D, et al. [29]

2014

Case Control

Fukuda

Serum

MBAA

Belgium

13

11

Peterson, et al. [30]

2015

Case Control

Fukuda

CSF

MBAA

U.S.A.

18

5

Repka-Ramirez, et al. [31]

2002

Case Control

Fukuda

Nasal Lavage

ELISA

U.S.A.

95

89

Russell, et al. [32]

2016

Case Control

ICC

Serum

ELISA

U.S.A.

50

69

Suhadolnik, et al. [33]

2004

Case Control

Fukuda

Serum

ELISA

U.S.A.

66

62

Tomoda et al. [34]

2005

Case Control

Fukuda

Serum

ELISA

Japan

15

23

  1. Dx CFS/ME diagnostic criteria used, HC healthy control(s), ELISA enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, MBAA multiplex bead array assay, CCC Canadian Consensus Criteria, ICC International Consensus Criteria, CSF cerebrospinal fluid
  2. This table is a summary of the characteristics of the included studies