Skip to main content

Table 4 Results – Economic burden (fatigue assessed as categorical)

From: Prevalence and burden of multiple sclerosis-related fatigue: a systematic literature review

Author (year)

Type of Analysis

Sample Size (n)

Cut-off for Fatigue

Outcome

Predictor(s)

Value

95% CI

p-value

da Silva (2016)

Multivariate ANOVA

210

MFIS Low impact (39–58), High impact (≥ 59)

Non-DMT costs

EDSS, gender, educational level, MFIS-BR (cut-off NR), MS relapse, any self-reported comorbidities, MS type, and occupation

NR

NR

0.83

Doesburg (2019)

Multiple logistic regression

78

NFI-MS Low (0–10 pts), Middle (11–20), High (21–30)

High work absence

Marital status, relapses in the past year, NFI-MS (middle vs low)

OR = 1.41

0.42, 4.76

0.581

Marital status, relapses in the past year, NFI-MS (high vs low)

OR = 15.80

3.00, 83.26

0.001

Marital status, relapses in the past year, NFI-MS (high vs middle)

OR = 11.22

2.13, 59.16

NR

Grytten (2017)

Univariate logistic regression

91

FSS ≥ 4

Unemployment at baseline

FSS ≥ 4

OR = 3.03

1.19, 7.71

0.02

Univariate Cox regression

40

Time to awarding disability pension

HR = 2.03

0.86, 4.78

0.09

Koziarska (2018)

Multivariate logistic regression

150

FSS > 4

Unemployment

FSS > 4, EDSS > 3, PQD5, KNS

OR = 2.63

1.02, 6.90

0.046

Lorefice (2018)

Multivariate logistic regression

123

FSS > 4

Unemployment status

Female, age, education, age at onset of MS, disease duration, EDSS, AES-S > 35, BDI-II > 14, FSS > 4

OR = 2.10

NR

0.179

McKay (2018)

Generalized estimating equations

340

D-FIS ≥ 5

Hospitalizations

Age, sex, EDSS, D-FIS ≥ 5, comorbidity count, HUI pain

adjRR = 1.82

0.86, 3.87

NR

Physician visit

Age, sex, D-FIS ≥ 5, smoker, comorbidity count, HUI pain, HUI cognition

adjRR = 1.06

0.97, 1.17

NR

Razazian (2014)

Pearson’s χ2 test

300

FSS ≥ 5

Medication use

FSS ≥ 5 vs FSS < 5

NR

NR

0.002

Employment status

FSS ≥ 5 vs FSS < 5

NR

NR

0.025

Salter (2017)

Multivariable logistic regression

4607

FPS Normal (0), Mild (1, 2), Moderate-to-severe (3–5)

Not working

MS clinical course, age, age at diagnosis, sex, number of comorbidity categories, CPS, FPS severe (vs. normal), HPS, PDDS

OR = 1.93

1.64, 2.26

<  0.0001

1921

Working < 35 h/week

OR = 1.63

1.04, 2.33

0.0031

1788

Cut back hrs. Past 6 mos.

OR = 7.19

3.29, 15.70

<  0.0001

1706

Missed work days past 6 mos.

OR = 4.73

2.67, 8.37

<  0.0001

1717

Receiving disability benefits

OR = 1.99

1.39, 2.84

0.0005

Weiland (2015)

Binary logistic regression

2133

FSS ≥ 4

FSS ≥ 4

Work part time

OR = 1.58

1.24, 2.02

≤ 0.001

Stay at home parent/carer

OR = 19.4

1.36, 2.77

≤ 0.001

Unemployed

OR = 2.15

1.48, 3.11

≤ 0.001

Retired due to disability

OR = 5.54

4.11, 7.47

≤ 0.001

Retired due to age

OR = 1.59

0.94, 2.67

NR

Other (inc. student)

OR = 0.834

0.55,1.27

NR

  1. Abbreviations: adjRR adjusted rate ratio, AES-S Apathy Evaluation Scale, ANOVA analysis of variance, BDI-II Beck Depression Inventory-Second Edition, CI confidence interval, CPS Cognition Performance Scale, D-FIS daily FIS, EDSS Expanded Disability Status Scale, FIS Fatigue Impact Scale, FPS Fatigue Performance Scale, FSS Fatigue Severity Scale, HPS Hand function Performance Scale, HR hazard ratio, hrs. hours, HUI Health Utility Index, KNS Hope for Success Questionnaire, MFIS modified FIS, MFIS-BR MFIS Brazilian Portuguese version, mos. months, NFIS-MS/BR Neurological Fatigue Index – Multiple Sclerosis, Brazilian Portuguese version, NR not reported, OR odds ratio, PDDS Patient Determined Disease Steps, PQD5 Perceived Deficits Questionnaire 5-items version, VAS visual analogue scale