Study | Crossover and reason(%) | Sheath size | Catheter type | Access-related complications(%) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Brunet et al. [7] | TRA 1.2%, TF 10.6%, artery spasm,inability to cannulate the artery,arteria lusoria configuration | 5 F Glidesheath Slidesheath | NR | 0 |
Chalouhi et al. [8] | TRA 10% | 5 F Prelude sheath | 5 F Simmons 2 | 0 |
Patel et al. [9] | TRA 5.9%, TF 5.9%, radial artery vasospasm | 5 F Prelude Ideas, 5 F Glidesheath Slender | 5 F Simmons 2 | wrist pain 5.9% |
Chivot et al. [10] | TF 1.3%, artery spasm | 5 F radial sheath | 4 F vertebral catheters supported by 5 F Extra Back Up | distal RAO 1.3%, minor forearm blanching 1.3% |
Hoffman et al. [11] | TF 1.3%, radial artery vasospasm, inability to cannulate the radial artery and brachiocephalic artery tortuosity | 5 F Glidesheath Slender | Simmons 2, angled glide | minor hematomas,vasospasm, radial artery perforation, pain (total 5.2%) |
Saito et al. [12] | TRA 7.8%, NR | 4 F Slit Super-Sheath | 4 F Simmons 2,4 F JB2 | minor hematomas 11.8%, numbness 2% |
Hoffman et al. [13] | NR 1.3%, NR | 5 F Glidesheath Slender | Simmons 2, angled glide | minor hematomas 1.3%, vasospasm 1.3%, radial artery perforation 1.3% |
Kühn et al. [14] | TF 10.4%, tortuous aortic arch tortuous | 6 F Prelude Ideal hydrophilic sheath | Benchmark 60.5%, Fubuki 18.6%, others 20.9% | radial artery vasospasm 4.2%, distal and RAO 2.1% |
Rodriguez et al. [15] | TRA 1%, TF 3%, puncture failure, arterial loop at the elbow, catheterize difficulty | 5-6 F thinner wall sheath,6 F Ballast,Cook Shuttle,Neuron MAX | sheathless technique | minor hematomas 3%, distal RAO 1%, radial stenosis 2% |
Weinberg et al. [16] | 0 | 5 F 94.2%,6 F 5.8% | NR | minor wrist hematoma 0.8%, radial artery vasospasm 0.8% |
Manzoor et al. [17] | TRA 2.6%, TF 1.8%, TUA 0.9%, puncture failure, artery vasospasm | 4-6 F Glidesheath Slender | 6 F Benchmark,sheathless technique | minor hematomas 2.6% |
Umekawa et al. [18] | TRA 23%, NR | 4 F Medikit sheath,6 F FUBUKI,8 F Optimo | 4 F MS2, Simmons C supported by 6 F FUBUKI and 8 F Optimo | minor hematomas 3.3% |
Goland et al. [19] | TRA 52.1%, TF 28.7%, NR | 6 F sheath | Simmons supported by Chaperon,Guider SofTip XF 6 F,Navien,Sophia | NR |
Ahmed et al. [20] | TF 3.1%, near occlusion of radial artery, right brachiocephalic artery tortuosity, aortic arch variable configuration | NR | NR | radial artery injury 1.6% |
Kühn et al. [21] | TF 9.1%, radial artery vasospasm, tortuous vessel anatomy and type 3 aortic arch | 6 F Prelude Ideal hydrophilic sheath 77.3%, 7 F sheath 4.5%, sheathless 18.2% | Benchmark, 5-7 F Fubuki,Select Flex 072 | 0 |
Chivot et al. [22] | TF 1.6%, humeral artery spasm | 6 F sheath | NR | 0 |
Kühn et al. [23] | TF 9.1%, brachial artery fibromuscular dysplasia | 6 F Prelude Ideal hydrophilic sheath,sheathless | 5 F Sofia supported by 6 F Benchmark,6 F Fubuki sheathless technique | 0 |