Intracisternal tuberculoma: a refractory type of tuberculoma indicating surgical intervention
BMC Neurology volume 18, Article number: 10 (2018)
Central nervous system (CNS) tuberculoma is a rare disease with severe neurological deficits. This retrospective research is to review the data of patients diagnosed as CNS tuberculoma. Surgeries were performed in all patients. The clinical features especially the neurological image and the anatomical characters of the tuberculomas were concerned.
Totally 11 patients diagnosed as CNS tuberculoma were admitted in Guangzhou First People’s Hospital (7cases) and Changzheng Hospital (4 cases) during 2006–2015. The data including preoperative condition, neurological imaging, and surgical findings was collected and analyzed.
The lesions of nine patients (9/11) were totally or subtotally excised and two (2/11) were partially excised. Neurological functions of all patients were improved after surgery without secondary infection. Lesions of nine (9/11) patients preoperatively progressed as a result of paradoxical reaction. Of the 9 patients demonstrated paradoxical progression, all lesions were partially or totally located at the cisterns or the subarachnoid space. Preoperative ATTs lasted 2 to 12 months and tuberculomas were not eliminated. The arachnoid was found thickened and tightly adhered to the lesions during surgeries. Of the 2 cases that paradoxical reaction were excluded, both patients (case 6, intramedullary tuberculoma; case 11, intradural extramedullary tuberculoma) were admitted at onset of the disease. ATTs were preoperatively given for 1 week as neurological deficits aggravated. The tuberculous lesions of CNS or other system showed no obvious change and paradoxical reaction could not be established in both cases.
Exudates of tuberculosis is usually accumulated in the cisterns and frequently results in the paradoxical formation of tuberculoma. Intracisternal tuberculoma is closely related to paradoxical reaction and refractory to anti-tuberculosis therapy. Micro-surgical excision is safe and effective. Early surgical intervention may be considered in the diagnosis of intracisternal tuberculoma especially when paradoxical reaction participates in the development of tuberculoma.
Tuberculosis (TB) with central nervous system (CNS) involvement occurs in approximately 1% of all TB patients and causes the highest morbidity and mortality . CNS tuberculosis has various forms. Tuberculous meningitis (TM) is the most frequent form of CNS TB and CNS tuberculoma is the type next to TM [2, 3]. Spinal intradural tuberculomas including intramedullary and intradural extramedullary tuberculoma are exceptionally rare and account for approximate 2%–5% of all CNS tuberculoma . Furthermore, Intradural extramedullary tuberculoma of the spinal cord is the most unusual type .
Although CNS tuberculoma is an uncommon disease, it usually presents with severe neurological deficits including altered mental status, hydrocephalus, cranial nerve palsies, hemiparesis and seizures et al. . Anti-tuberculosis treatments (ATT) combined with surgeries in the treatment of CNS tuberculoma have been reported occasionally [7, 8]. However, most of the articles mainly described the rarity of this disease and clinical situation including diagnosis, medications and outcomes of surgeries [9,10,11,12]. The locations, possible pathogenesis and the relation between them were not mentioned in those reported cases, except for the optochiasmatic tuberculoma .
Of the patients in this study, we were aware of the characteristics that the subarachnoid space including cerebral cisterns and spinal subarachnoid space were susceptible regions for the formation of tuberculomas following TM and/or tuberculous arachnoiditis. This situation was also noticed by other doctors [4, 14]. Paradoxical reaction, defined as an phenomenon of effective medical treatment demonstrating opposite effect in certain lesions [15, 16], is prone to occur at the cisterns and frequently results in the formation of intracisternal tuberculoma [17, 18]. In most cases, ATT is effective in treating the CNS tuberculoma . Unfortunately, when paradoxical reaction participates in the etiology of tuberculoma, the effectiveness of ATT is usually limited and additional corticosteroids is indicated . Nevertheless, long period of medical therapy for resolving the lesion results in limited improvement or even deterioration of the impaired neurological function, especially for the spinal paradoxical tuberculoma . From the above information, intracisternal tuberculoma, paradoxical reaction and their intimate relation result in the severity and difficulty of medicine treatment. Accordingly, rapid elimination of the tuberculoma by surgical intervention should be considered.
This retrospective research was approved by the ethics committee of Guangzhou First People’s Hospital and Changzheng Hospital. From 2006 to 2015, 11 patients diagnosed as CNS tuberculoma requiring surgical intervention were admitted in the neurosurgery department of Guangzhou First People’s Hospital, Guangdong, China and Changzheng Hospital, Shanghai. All patients underwent surgical excision of tuberculoma. Preoperative sputum smear was negative of tubercle bacillus of all patients. The diagnosis of tuberculosis of nine cases (pulmonary or CNS) was established in specialized hospital for tuberculosis. Two patients were diagnosed as spinal tuberculoma at onset of the disease and adequate ATT was administered for 1 week before sugeries. The age of patients ranged from 7 to 52 years old. Six patients were female and five were male. Of the nine patients with preoperative diagnosis of tuberculosis, effective ATT was applied. Effectiveness of ATT was evidenced by the improvement of the clinical symptom and radiological findings (including pulmonary or most part of the CNS lesions). However, new lesions or progression of one lesion was found in these nine patients in later period during the ATT. Paradoxical reactions were identified in these nine patients and additional corticosteroid was administered. Paradoxical reaction was not considered in the patient presenting intramedullary tuberculoma and the patient with intradural extramedullary tuberculoma of the fifth thoracic vertebra as both patients presented tuberculomas initially. For the two patients, surgeries were performed 1 week after ATT initiated as negative sputums for tubercle bacillus were confirmed. As shown in Table 1, the location of symptom related tuberculoma included the cerebral hemispheres (three cases), posterior fossa (three cases), and spinal (five cases, including one case of intramedullary tuberculoma and four cases of intradural extramedullary tuberculoma.).
All patients were given routine examinations of blood, blood electrolyte, liver function and kidney function. Electrocardiography and chest radiography were performed to exclude cardiac or pulmonary contraindications for surgeries. Sputum smears were performed repetitively assuring negative result of tubercle bacillus. MRI was acquired for a preoperative evaluation. ATT based on the regimen of specialized hospital for treatment of tuberculosis and was continued during the entire hospital stay of the patient.
Two patients experienced two surgeries. One patient (patient 7) with tuberculoma locating at dorsal pons to cerebellum (cisterna ambiens) received external draininage of the tuberculoma at local hospital and relapsed after 2 months. A microsurgical excision was given by our team. Another patient (patient 3) with intradural extramedullary tuberculoma (co-existing with an intramedullary lesion situating at the ventral spinal cord without surgical intervention) underwent two surgeries for the intradural extramedullary tuberculoma. Other patients underwent operations once respectively. The symptom-inducing lesion was the surgical target in patient with multiple lesions. For example, patient 2 (Fig. 2c, d), the lesion locating at right cisterna magna (Fig. 2c, white arrow) was responsible for the hydrocephalus and hemiparesis. This lesion was the target of surgery. The lesion of left cerebellum was small and asymptomatic (Fig. 2c, d, red arrow). This lesion with other supratentorial lesions was resolved by the effective ATT. Precautions were taken to protect the surrounding normal brain tissue from surgical contamination. For the spinal tuberculomas, pedicle screw fixation surgeries were performed if necessary. All patients were followed until the present time. Follow-ups were performed by telephone or at outpatient department in all patients.
Preoperative MRI findings
For CNS tuberculoma, MRI is the most important examination for preoperative preparation. The lesions showed hypo- to iso-intense on T1WI (Fig. 1a) and mixed signal intensity on T2WI (Fig. 1b). Contrast-enhanced T1WI sequence displayed isolated or conglomerated ring enhancing lesions accompanied with hypo-intense non-enhancing content inside in most situations (Fig. 1c, 2a, c).
This group of patients contained various locations of the CNS including temporal lobe, frontal lobe, cerebello-pontine angle, cerebella and intravertebral canal. It is noteworthy that except one intramedullary tuberculoma case, all other cases were associated with the subarachnoid space, including the sylvian fissure (Fig. 2a), cerebellopontine angle (Fig. 1c), ambient cistern (Fig. 5a), cerebellomedullary cistern (Fig. 2c) and the subarachnoid space of the spinal cord (Fig. 3a).
Patient 3 presented with coexisting intramedullary (Fig. 3a-d, red arrows) and intradural extramedullary lesions (Fig. 3,the continuous enhancing intradural extramedullary lesion from T3-T9). Preoperative evaluation identified that the lesions responsible for the symptoms were the multiple intradural extramedullary tuberculomas. Given that the intramedullary lesion was located at the ventral spinal cord, a direct excision of the intramedullary lesion might cause further spinal injury to the spinal function that was already seriously damaged, the intramedullary lesion was not resected. A laminectomy of T3-T4, T7-T9 or the excision of the corresponding extramedullary lesions was performed (Fig. 3b). However, the lesion of T9 was missed(Fig. 3b, white arrow). After 2 months of ATT, the following situations were displayed: extramedullary lesion of T9 enlarged (Fig. 3c, white arrow); the residual lesion of T5-T6 disappeared; the intramedullary lesion showed no change (Fig. 3a-c). A second time surgery was performed to remove the progressing extramedullary lesion of T9. At the same time, a pedicle screw fixation was performed to maintain the stability of the spinal column (Fig. 3d).
The intramedullary tuberculoma was revealed to be well-defined lesions (Fig. 4a) which is totally different for the intradural extramedullary tuberculoma. As for the latter, the abscess extended on the surface of spinal cord (Fig. 4b). The irregular lesion adhere to surrounding tissues intimately. Similar situation was oberserved in the cerebral tuberculoma. Even for the same tuberculoma, the interface between the tuberculoma and parenchyma was relatively loose and easy to be separated (Fig. 5e, white arrow displayed the interface of the tuberculoma and the parenchyma of brain) while the adhesion of tuberculoma in the subarachnoid space was tight (Fig. 5f, white arrow displayed the adhesion of tuberculoma and arachnoid). This kind of close relation between subarachnoid space and the cisternal part of tuberculoma was due to the thickening arachnoid, the hyperplastic fibrous tissue closely surrounding the lesion. Coagulation and sharp dissection is necessary for separation. Furthermore, manipulation in the cisternal part of tuberculoma should be more careful as vital vessel may course in the cistern. Decisions of cutting or separation and reservation the vessel should be done based on clear identification (Fig. 5g, red arrow indicates the vessel after separation of arachnoid).
None of the patients experienced secondary infection following the surgical procedures. All of the patients were followed from the date of surgery until the present time. The outcomes of all patients were evaluated with Karnofsky Performance Scale in different neurological recovery periods. The recovery times of patients in this study were different. For the most severe case as case 3, 40 months had passed before the patient finally carried out daily activities (KPS was 90). For the other patient, it took about 2–6 months for recovery (KPS were 90–100).
All specimens were pathologically analyzed. The pathological characteristics including granulomas, necrosis, caseation, cell types (lymphocyte, Langerhans-type giant cell), and the result of acid-fast bacillus staining were recorded. Not all the pathological features were demonstrated in one case. Typical tuberculomas showed a granulomatous reaction consisting of epithelioid cells and giant cells mixed with mononuclear inflammatory cells (predominantly lymphocytes) that form a granuloma (Fig. 6b, c) [6, 21].
CNS tuberculoma is a devastating disease with high morbidity and mortality. Although the outcome of the patients in this study was encouraging, the periods of preoperative ATT (for the paradoxical tuberculoma) were 2 to 12 months (average 5.9 ± 4.0 months). Neurological functions in most cases were aggravated during the ATT treatment as a result of a paradoxical reaction which limited the effect of ATT. Surgical excision of the lesion was a turning point for this group of patients. To our opinion, early surgical excision is an appropriate procedure when a paradoxical lesion formed. This is particularly critical for spinal tuberculoma [1, 22].
Although the clinical situations of the patients were different, for example the sites of the lesions and the response to treatment, we noticed that the tuberculoma of nine (9/11) patients who were considered paradoxical tuberculoma were correlated with the subarachnoid space. Furthermore, it was intriguing that the relapsed lesions of the two patients who experienced local recurrence were located at the dorsal ambient cistern or spinal subarachnoid space, respectively. We identified the thickening arachnoid adhered to the lesion during the surgery as described in previous literature . The subarachnoid space involvement accompanied with the thickening arachnoid seems to be a potential risk factor for the occurrence and recurrence of tuberculoma. Meanwhile, frequent occurence of paradoxical reaction in the subarachnoid space furtherly proved the refractory nature of intracisternal tuberculoma.
Tuberculoma is frequently developed in subarachnoid space as a result of paradoxical reaction
The classical model of TM pathology suggests two steps of the pathological process of tuberculosis meningitis. Firstly, the mycobacteria begins to grow at the parenchyma or meninges of the brain or spinal cord, and then develops and matures into a tuberculous abscess. Secondly, the abscess breaks up and releases its contents into the subarachnoid space which causes TM . TM may also be the result of the direct hematogenous spread of pulmonary tuberculosis . Based on above knowledge, tuberculoma and TM may be considered as the initial manifestations of the CNS tuberculous pathology. More importantly, the subarachnoid space is a pathological and anatomical region where mycobacteria and its products frequently exist. The exudates of TM and the arachnoiditis usually accumulate at the subarachnoid space including the interpeduncular cisterns, optochiasmatic cistern, the ambient and the suprasellar cisterns, the sylvian fissures as well as the subarachnoid space of spine . Spinal subarachnoid space is anatomically similar to the cerebral cisterns. This explained the facts that intradural extramedullary tuberculoma was closely related to the arachnoiditis as well . Pathological progression following cisternal exudates includes arachnoiditis and tuberculoma [4, 11, 24]. This kind of cisternal tuberculoma displayed its own features other than the parenchymal tuberculoma. The gelatinous exudate is constrained by the hyperplastic thickened arachnoid whereas the exudate still could spread in the cistern. This illustrates multiple lobular tuberculoma is common in the images of published articles and in our cases which is different from the parenchymal tuberculoma (Fig. 1c, 2a) . The adhesion of arachnoid led to the formation of the inter-septum of the tuberculoma. More importantly, the exudates in the cistern was considered a form of the paradoxical response . Accordingly, tuberculoma secondary to the cisternal exudate was a product of paradoxical reaction too. It was reported the optochiasmatic region had a high propensity for accumulating a quantity of exudates, which was a frequent type of paradoxical reaction .
Intracisternal tuberculoma is refractory to ATT and an indication for surgical intervention
Based on the above information, because the cisternal tuberculoma shows a high rate of paradoxical development, the effectiveness of ATT is limited . The immunological reaction based paradoxical reaction results in the progression of the lesion which calls for additional corticosteroids but no needs of change of ATT regimen . Thus, prolonged therapeutic time is inevitable. At the same time, the paradoxical progression of the intracisternal lesion furtherly damages the neurological function which indicates surgery. Natarajan et al. believed that paradoxical intraduaral extramedullary tuberculoma was an indication for surgery . According to our findings, the relatively enclosed space of a tuberculoma-occupying cistern which impedes the flow of CSF may result in a low concentration of medicine in the area. In the two relapsed cases reported in our study, the lesions were both situated in the subarachnoid space. As for the case of the tuberculoma locating at the ambient cistern to the cerebellum, even the drainage surgery had a limited effect and did not change the microenvironment of the intracisternal tuberculoma (case 7). Finally, the safety of microsurgical excision had been proven as no secondary infection or dissemination was observed in literatures or our cases [9, 26]. All these factors ensure us that surgical resection should be early considered for the intracisternal tuberculoma.
Intracisternal tuberculoma is accompanied with serious neurological deficits requiring early resolving of the lesions
As mentioned above, Intracisternal tuberculoma is frequently progressed from paradoxical reaction and fast elimination of the lesions was usually difficult. It is worse that the exudates, arachnoiditis and/or tuberculoma developing in the cistern and adjacent parenchyma furtherly damage the neurological functions . Tuberculoma in the cistern blocks the circulation of CSF resulting in hydrocephalus. The mass effect and surrounding edema may lead to the occurrence of hernia or the compression of vital structures of the CNS in certain areas. The exudates and tuberculoma can affect the blood vessels arranged in the area causing vasculitis and subsequently stroke . In a univariate analysis, sylvian fissure exudates were predictors of stroke . The critical site of the intracisternal tuberculoma also requires more attention especially surgical consideration.
Intracisternal and intradural extramedullary tuberculoma are specific forms of tuberculoma requiring particular attention. Exudates accumulation and arachnoiditis are the pathological changes occurring in these areas. Meanwhile, paradoxical reaction frequently participates in the formation of tuberculoma in these regions. This kind of intracisternal tuberculoma is refractory to ATT and corticosteroids which may take a long period to get the lesion resolved and potentially induce severe neurological injury. Surgical excision is an inevitable and necessary procedure for intracisternal tuberculoma for improving neurological function.
Central nervous system
Cerebral spinal fluid
Magnetic resonance imaging
DeLance AR, Safaee M, MC O, Clark AJ, Kaur G, Sun MZ, Bollen AW, Phillips JJ, Parsa AT. Tuberculoma of the central nervous system. J Clin Neurosci. 2013;20(10):1333–41.
Skendros P, Kamaria F, Kontopoulos V, Tsitouridis I, Sidiropoulos L. Intradural, eextramedullary tuberculoma of the spinal cord as a complication of tuberculous meningitis. Infection. 2003;31(2):115–7.
Das KK, Jaiswal S, Shukla M, Srivastava AK, Behari S, Kumar R. Concurrent cerebellar and cervical intramedullary tuberculoma: paradoxical response on antitubercular chemotherapy and need for surgery. J Pediatr Neurosci. 2014;9(2):162–5.
Luo L, Pino J. An intradural extramedullary tuberculoma of the spinal cord in a non-HIV-infected patient: case report and review of the literature. Lung. 2006;184(3):187–93.
Dastur HM. Diagnosis and neurosurgical treatment of tuberculous disease of the CNS. Neurosurg Rev. 1983;6(3):111–7.
Thwaites GE, van Toorn R, Schoeman J. Tuberculous meningitis: more questions, still too few answers. The Lancet Neurology. 2013;12(10):999–1010.
Muthukumar N, Sureshkumar V, Ramesh VG. En plaque intradural extramedullary spinal tuberculoma and concurrent intracranial tuberculomas: paradoxical response to antituberculous therapy. Case report. Journal of neurosurgery Spine. 2007;6(2):169–73.
Rajshekhar V. Surgery for brain tuberculosis: a review. Acta Neurochir. 2015;157(10):1665–78.
Li H, Liu W, You C. Central nervous system tuberculoma. J Clin Neurosci. 2012;19(5):691–5.
Botturi A, Prodi E, Silvani A, Gaviani P, Vanoli G, Carbone A, Salmaggi A. Brain tuberculoma (Mycobacterium Africanum): high index of suspicion helps in avoiding biopsy/surgery. Neurol Sci. 2012;33(2):363–5.
Roca B. Intradural extramedullary tuberculoma of the spinal cord: a review of reported cases. The Journal of infection. 2005;50(5):425–31.
Shingade RG, Prakashchandra SP. Role of advanced diagnostic imaging in intracranial Tuberculoma: MR spectroscopy. J Clin Diagn Res. 2015;9(8):TJ03–4.
Akhaddar A, El Hassani MY, Chakir N, Jiddane M. Optochiasmatic tuberculoma: complication of tuberculous meningitis. Report of a case and review of the literature. Journal of neuroradiology Journal de neuroradiologie. 2001;28(2):137–42.
Chang KH, Han MH, Choi YW, Kim IO, Han MC, Kim CW. Tuberculous arachnoiditis of the spine: findings on myelography, CT, and MR imaging. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 1989;10(6):1255–62.
Afghani B, Lieberman JM. Paradoxical enlargement or development of intracranial tuberculomas during therapy: case report and review. Clin Infect Dis. 1994;19(6):1092–9.
Nicolls DJ, King M, Holland D, Bala J, del Rio C. Intracranial tuberculomas developing while on therapy for pulmonary tuberculosis. Lancet Infect Dis. 2005;5(12):795–801.
Schoeman JF, Donald PR. Tuberculous meningitis. Handb Clin Neurol. 2013;112:1135–8.
Verma R, Patil TB, Lalla R. Tuberculous optochiasmatic arachnoiditis. J Global Infect Dis. 2014;6(2):89.
Idris MN, Sokrab TE, Arbab MA, Ahmed AE, El Rasoul H, Ali S, Elzubair MA, Mirgani SM. Tuberculoma of the brain: a series of 16 cases treated with anti-tuberculosis drugs. The international journal of tuberculosis and lung disease. 2007;11(1):91–5.
Dheda K, Barry CE 3rd, Maartens G. Tuberculosis. Lancet. 2016;387(10024):1211–26.
Garg RK. Tuberculosis of the central nervous system. Postgrad Med J. 1999;75(881):133–40.
Fox GJ, Mitnick CD, Benedetti A, Chan ED, Becerra M, Chiang CY, Keshavjee S, Koh WJ, Shiraishi Y, Viiklepp P, et al. Surgery as an adjunctive treatment for multidrug-resistant tuberculosis: an individual patient data Metaanalysis. Clin Infect Dis. 2016;62(7):887–95.
Garg RK, Malhotra HS, Kumar N. Paradoxical reaction in HIV negative tuberculous meningitis. J Neurol Sci. 2014;340(1–2):26–36.
Garg RK, Paliwal V, Malhotra HS. Tuberculous optochiasmatic arachnoiditis: a devastating form of tuberculous meningitis. Expert Rev Anti-Infect Ther. 2011;9(9):719–29.
Sinha MK, Garg RK, Anuradha HK, Agarwal A, Parihar A, Mandhani PA. Paradoxical vision loss associated with optochiasmatic tuberculoma in tuberculous meningitis: a report of 8 patients. The Journal of infection. 2010;60(6):458–66.
Jha D, Khatri P, Choudhary A, Sethi R, Kumar S. Endoscopic third ventriculostomy in prepontine-suprasellar tuberculoma with tuberculous meningitis hydrocephalus: a case report. Pediatr Neurosurg. 2007;43(1):42–6.
Schoeman JF, Van Zyl LE, Laubscher JA, Donald PR, Serial CT. Scanning in childhood tuberculous meningitis: prognostic features in 198 cases. J Child Neurol. 1995;10(4):320–9.
Cherian A, Thomas SV. Central nervous system tuberculosis. Afr Health Sci. 2011;11(1):116–27.
We acknowledge Dr. Bing Luo, Jian Su, Hengchang Li and Zeng Yang for the clinical help; Dr. Xiangdong Xu for the MRI.
This work including the data collection, analysis and interpretation, manuscript revising was supported by National Natural Science Fund of China (81302187), PLA logistics research project (CWS14C063) and Fund of State Key Laboratory of Drug Research (SIMM1705KF-10).
Availability of data and materials
The materials described in the manuscript, including all relevant raw data, will be freely available to any scientist wishing to use them for non-commercial purposes, without breaching participant confidentiality under the circumstances without conflicting to our further research.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This retrospective research was approved by the ethics committee of Guangzhou First People’s Hospital and Changzheng Hospital.
Consent for publication
Informed consents to publish were obtained from the patients with individual data involved in this article.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Chen, F., Chen, L., Cao, Y. et al. Intracisternal tuberculoma: a refractory type of tuberculoma indicating surgical intervention. BMC Neurol 18, 10 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12883-017-0996-x