- Research article
- Open Access
The thalamus in trigeminal neuralgia: structural and metabolic abnormalities, and influence on surgical response
BMC Neurology volume 21, Article number: 290 (2021)
Medically-refractory trigeminal neuralgia (TN) can be treated successfully with operative intervention, but a significant proportion of patients are non-responders despite undergoing technically successful surgery. The thalamus is a key component of the trigeminal sensory pathway involved in transmitting facial pain, but the role of the thalamus in TN, and its influence on durability of pain relief after TN surgery, are relatively understudied. We aimed to test the hypothesis that variations in thalamic structure and metabolism are related to surgical non-response in TN.
We performed a longitudinal, peri-operative neuroimaging study of the thalamus in medically-refractory TN patients undergoing microvascular decompression or percutaneous balloon compression rhizotomy. Patients underwent structural MRI and MR spectroscopy scans pre-operatively and at 1-week following surgery, and were classified as responders or non-responders based on 1-year post-operative pain outcome. Thalamus volume, shape, and metabolite concentration (choline/creatine [Cho/Cr] and N-acetylaspartate/creatine [NAA/Cr]) were evaluated at baseline and 1-week, and compared between responders, non-responders, and healthy controls.
Twenty healthy controls and 23 patients with medically-refractory TN treated surgically (17 responders, 6 non-responders) were included. Pre-operatively, TN patients as a group showed significantly larger thalamus volume contralateral to the side of facial pain. However, vertex-wise shape analysis showed significant contralateral thalamus volume reduction in non-responders compared to responders in an axially-oriented band spanning the outer thalamic circumference (peak p = 0.019). Further, while pre-operative thalamic metabolite concentrations did not differ between responders and non-responders, as early as 1-week after surgery, long-term non-responders showed a distinct decrease in contralateral thalamic Cho/Cr and NAA/Cr, irrespective of surgery type, which was not observed in responders.
Atrophy of the contralateral thalamus is a consistent feature across patients with medically-refractory TN. Regional alterations in preoperative thalamic structure, and very early post-operative metabolic changes in the thalamus, both appear to influence the durability of pain relief after TN surgery.
Trigeminal neuralgia (TN) is a neuropathic facial pain disorder characterized by intermittent, typically unilateral attacks of lancinating pain in the distribution of one or more branches of the trigeminal nerve (cranial nerve V—CNV) . Though occasionally caused by intracranial lesions or multiple sclerosis, TN is typically non-lesional and categorized as: 1) classical TN, associated with neurovascular compression at the root entry zone (REZ) of CNV; or 2) idiopathic TN, without neurovascular compression. More than 50% of TN patients become medically-refractory , and are typically offered neurosurgical procedures targeting CNV directly, including microvascular decompression (MVD), percutaneous rhizotomy, or stereotactic radiosurgery. Unfortunately, post-surgical pain recurrence is not uncommon: even with MVD—the most efficacious surgical treatment—early recurrence within two years of surgery occurs in approximately 25% of patients, with a recurrence rate of 4% per year thereafter .
Given the strong association between TN and neurovascular compression at the CNV REZ, and reports of CNV atrophy in TN [4,5,6], several studies have used magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to examine CNV structure more closely, and its relationship to surgical outcome. In particular, diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) has revealed CNV microstructural abnormalities in TN, suggestive of de/dysmyelination or axon loss [5, 7,8,9,10]. DTI abnormalities in CNV may predict durability of pain relief after surgery [11, 12], but they are not conclusively superior to the prognostic value of clinical factors such as TN pain character, presence and degree of neurovascular compression, or female sex [13, 14]. Overall, there is still an incomplete understanding of the mechanisms underlying the failure of many TN patients to respond adequately to technically successful surgery. Identifying these mechanisms is important because such patients frequently undergo multiple repeat surgical interventions, with persistently diminished quality of life.
Beyond CNV, the trigeminal sensory system includes second-order neurons in brainstem nuclei receiving afferents from CNV which project—via the ventral trigeminothalamic tract—to third-order neurons residing in the contralateral ventral posteromedial nucleus (VPM) of the thalamus, that in turn project to the somatosensory cortex. Preliminary attempts to examine the brainstem with MRI in TN suggest that microstructural abnormalities exist upstream of CNV as well [15, 16], though DTI in the brainstem is technically challenging and susceptible to error . Despite the well-known structural and functional alterations of the thalamus in chronic pain , and its role in the trigeminal sensory system, very few TN studies have directly examined the thalamus or its relationship to treatment outcome [18,19,20,21]. Recently, we retrospectively identified pre-operative enlargement of the thalamus contralateral to the painful side of the face in patients with TN , though, whether thalamic volume is related to surgical outcome per se remains uncertain.
Accordingly, the motivation for this study was to further elucidate the role of the thalamus in TN. We hypothesized that TN patients exhibit characteristic structural and metabolic abnormalities in the thalamus, and further that these abnormalities are associated with surgical outcome in TN. To test our hypothesis, we used structural MRI and 1H-magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) to evaluate the thalamus in TN patients prior to surgery, to identify longitudinal changes in thalamus structure and metabolism occurring in these same patients in the early post-operative period, and to examine the relationship of both to durable post-operative pain relief.
This was a prospective, longitudinal study of patients undergoing surgical treatment for TN at a single centre between 2017 and 2020, approved by the Health Research Ethics Board—Health Panel of the University of Alberta. Potential study patients were identified in clinic by any one of three neurosurgeons (authors TS, BMW, RB) and provided informed consent. Inclusion criteria: medically-refractory classical or idiopathic TN defined using International Classification of Headache Disorders-III (ICHD-III) criteria; scheduled for surgical treatment by microvascular decompression (MVD) or percutaneous balloon compression rhizotomy (BC). Exclusion criteria: confirmed multiple sclerosis or other lesional causes of TN; diagnosed psychiatric illness; history of any prior non-TN neurosurgical procedures. Additionally, 20 healthy control (HC) subjects matched to the TN group in mean age and sex distribution, and without chronic pain or psychiatric conditions, were recruited.
TN patients underwent MRI scanning within 1-month prior to surgery (pre-operative time-point) and at 5–12 days following surgery (1-week post-operative time-point). HC subjects underwent a single MRI scanning session. Scanning was carried out on a 3 T Siemens Prisma Magnetom MRI scanner (Erlangen, Germany) with 64-channel head radiofrequency coil. At every MRI acquisition, participants underwent: 3D T1-weighted structural scan (magnetization-prepared rapid acquisition gradient echo (MPRAGE), field-of-view (FOV) = 250 × 250mm2, 208 sagittal slices, 0.85 mm isotropic, repetition time (TR) = 1800 ms, echo time (TE) = 2.37 ms, inversion time (TI) = 900 ms, 8° flip angle, 3:41 min), and 2-dimentional multivoxel MRS scan centred over the VPM thalamus (see below for details) in the coronal-orientation (point-resolved spectroscopy (PRESS), FOV = 160 × 160mm2, 1 slice, interpolated voxel size = 5 mm x 5 mm x 10 mm, TR = 1700 ms, TE = 35 ms, 90° flip angle, 1024 repetitions, 2 averages, time = 14:37 min). Participants also completed a pain questionnaire describing pain attack frequency, location, and severity measured with a 0-100 mm Visual Analogue Scale (VAS). All participants were followed for at least 12-months following surgery.
Clinical characteristics and outcome assessment
The following demographic/clinical data were collected: sex; age; duration of TN since diagnosis; side-of-pain; pre-operative pain severity (measured using VAS); first (virgin) or repeat surgical treatment for TN; surgery type (MVD or BC); and medications. Additionally, we determined neurovascular compression (NVC) severity scores for each patient based on the scoring system of Sindou et al. (0: no neurovascular contact or venous contact alone; 1: arterial contact with no indentation of nerve root; 2: arterial contact with displacement and distortion of nerve root; 3: arterial contact with marked indentation in nerve root). NVC severity scores were derived by a single observer (author TS) by examining routine high resolution clinical pre-operative T2 weighted MRI scans, confirmed (in patients undergoing MVD) by intraoperative findings as indicated in operative reports. Note that, in our practice, patients who are found to have no compressive arterial NVC at the time of MVD also undergo internal neurolysis (IN). Study participants were classified as responders or non-responders as follows: responders – 1) documented evidence of immediate and persistent pain relief for at least one year after surgery (Barrow Neurological Institute (BNI) facial pain score IIIa or better) ; and 2) no offer of or repeat surgical TN treatment; non-responders – 1) inadequate initial pain relief from surgery or early pain recurrence within one year of surgery; or 2) offered or underwent repeat surgical treatment within one year.
Automated thalamus volumetry and shape analysis
T1-weighted MPRAGE images were used for thalamus volume and shape assessment. Image orientation depended on the analysis performed: 1) native orientation analysis—images remained unflipped, in their native orientation; 2) ipsilateral orientation analysis—images from patients with left-sided TN were left–right flipped with FMRIB’s FSL toolbox  such that the side-of-pain was on the right side of the image, while images from right-sided TN patients were not flipped. This permitted ipsilateral to contralateral side-of-pain comparisons. FMRIB’s FSL brain tissue segmentation toolbox SIENAX  was used to generate brain tissue (grey matter, white matter, cerebrospinal fluid) volumes and an estimate of intracranial volume (v-scaling factor). Thalamus segmentations were derived using FSL-FIRST, part of the FSL toolkit (http://fsl.fmrib.ox.ac.uk/fsl/fslwiki/) . FIRST is a model-based segmentation tool that uses shape- and appearance-based models constructed from manually segmented images . Quality control was performed for each patient by two expert raters (authors HD and JA), who inspected all thalamus segmentations; evidence of mis-segmentation resulted in subject exclusion from volumetric analysis. Shape analysis was performed using the vertex analysis extension of the FSL-FIRST toolbox with the standard recommended parameters in the FSL user guide (https://fsl.fmrib.ox.ac.uk/fsl/fslwiki/FIRST/UserGuide) . Vertex-wise shape analysis was designed to assess between group differences on a per-vertex basis using a multi-variate General Linear Model. Meshes of the thalamus were generated for each subject, and to normalize for inter-individual head size differences, the meshes were reconstructed in MNI space. p < 0.05 was considered statistically significant, corrected for multiple comparisons (family wise error, FWE) using a cluster-wise approach.
Metabolic assessment of the thalamus
MRS images were used for metabolic assessment of the thalamus. Native orientation raw RDA image files for every time-point were processed using LCModel version 6.3-1L . Individual 1H spectra were generated for every interpolated voxel acquired. For every patient at every time point, an MRS voxel (5 × 5 x 10 mm) was placed bilaterally to encompass the left and right VPM thalamus, with the epicenter of each voxel defined according to the following atlas-based coordinates: x = 13 mm lateral to the mid-commissural point, y = 4 mm anterior to the posterior commissure, and z = 1 mm inferior to the mid-commissural point  (Supplementary Figure 1). Absolute concentrations of Choline (Cho), N-Acetylaspartate (NAA), and creatine (Cr) obtained from 1H spectra within each target voxel were combined to generate relative intra-voxel concentrations of Cho/Cr and NAA/Cr (using Cr as an internal reference), and subsequently used for all MRS analyses. All 1H spectra were visually inspected for quality control.
Within-group left-versus-right, or ipsilateral-versus-contralateral, comparisons of thalamus volume and metabolite concentration were performed using Wilcoxon signed-rank tests. In left-versus-right comparisons, we also calculated inter-hemispheric percent differences in volume and metabolite concentrations, using the following formulas: 1) in left TN patients, %interhemispheric difference = (right – left) / left * 100; 2) in right TN patients, %interhemispheric difference = (left – right) / right * 100. For HC subjects, the selected formula depended on the desired between-group comparison (left-sided TN vs. left-HC, formula #1; right-sided TN vs. right-HC, formula #2). Between-group comparisons were performed using Mann–Whitney tests. Within-patient comparisons of pre-operative versus 1-week post-operative thalamus metabolite concentrations were performed using Wilcoxon signed-rank tests. Clinical characteristics and demographic variables were compared using Mann–Whitney tests, as well as Chi-square or Fisher’s exact test where appropriate. Statistical analyses were carried out with GraphPad Prism version 8 for Mac OS X (GraphPad Software, La Jolla California, USA).
Statistical significance was set at p < 0.050 (2-tailed).
Twenty-three TN patients and 20 HC were included in this study between 2017 and 2020 (Table 1). All 23 TN patients were included in the volumetric analysis, while only 19 TN patients were included in the metabolite analysis because of inadequate spectral quality (n = 2) or failure to acquire MRS scans (n = 2).
Clinical characteristics and demographics
All TN: Clinical and demographic features of all 23 TN patients and 20 HCs are presented in Table 1. TN and HC (14F/9 M and 11F/9 M, p = 0.70). Average TN duration was 5.3 \(\pm\) 3.9 years, with right- groups were well matched in age (56.3 \(\pm\) 10.4 years and 54.9 \(\pm\) 9.4 years respectively, p = 0.65) and sex distribution sided TN more common than left-sided TN (15R/8L). Neurovascular compression was identified in 17/23 TN patients, and pre-operative VAS was 77.6 \(\pm\) 27.3 across the entire TN patient group. This study included virgin surgical procedures for 17/23 TN patients, with MVD most common (16 MVD, 7 BC). All TN patients were on antiepileptic medication at surgery, including carbamazepine/oxcarbazepine (n = 21) and/or gabapentin/pregabalin (n = 12). Three TN patients were also on antidepressant/anxiolytic medication, six were on baclofen, one was taking opioids, and two others were taking cannabis oil.
By response to surgery: In total, there were 17 responders to surgery and 6 non-responders. Non-responders were exclusively female (6F/0 M), while responders had a balanced sex distribution (8F/9 M). Non-responders were younger than responders (47.4 \(\pm\) 10.3 years and 58.6 \(\pm\) 9.7 years respectively, p = 0.016), and showed a trend toward longer duration of TN compared to responders (8.8 \(\pm\) 4.7 years versus 4.6 \(\pm\) 3.3 years respectively, p = 0.061). Neurovascular compression severity score was not statistically different between outcome groups (p = 0.64, Fisher’s exact test), nor was frequency of surgery type (p = 0.32, Chi-square test). The proportion of patients taking baclofen was higher in non-responders than responders (p = 0.021), with no other differences in medication use. Individual TN patient clinical profiles are presented in Table 2.
Native orientation analysis
In HCs, the volume of the left thalamus was larger than the right (8209, 7895–9195 IQR and 7985, 7607–8974 IQR respectively; p < 0.001). There was no difference between left and right thalamus volume across all TN patients together (8077, 7590–8520 IQR and 8138, 7665–8506 IQR respectively; p = 0.88) (data not shown). The volume of the thalamus contralateral to the side-of-pain was larger in TN patients: in left TN patients (LTN) the right thalamus was larger than the left (8308, 8017–8633 IQR and 8111, 7641–8168 IQR respectively; p = 0.008); in right TN patients (RTN) the left thalamus was larger than the right (7895, 7485–8520 IQR and 8258, 7665–8858 IQR respectively; p < 0.001) (Fig. 1A). TN was associated with altered interhemispheric asymmetry of thalamic volume: left versus right thalamus interhemispheric %volume difference differed between HC and LTN patients (-3.1, -4.1 to -2.3 IQR; 3.9, 2.8–5.8 IQR; p < 0.001), while there was no difference between HC and RTN patients (3.2, 2.4–4.3 IQR; 2.9, 2.3–4.0 IQR; p = 0.54) or between LTN and RTN (3.9, 2.8–5.8 IQR; 2.9, 2.3–4.0 IQR; p = 0.13) (Fig. 1B).
Ipsilateral orientation analysis
After flipping the brains of left TN patients, we found no differences between average HC thalamus volume (8087, 7763–9084 IQR) and ipsilateral (ips) or contralateral (cont) thalamus volume of responders (ips: 8083, 7639–8348 IQR, p = 0.54; cont: 8365, 7944–8766 IQR, p = 0.48) or non-responders (ips: 7571, 6988–8461 IQR, p = 0.093; cont: 7810, 7239–8695 IQR, p = 0.32). Thalamus volume contralateral to the side-of-pain was larger than ipsilateral to the side-of-pain in both responders (p < 0.001) and non-responders (p < 0.031) (Fig. 2A), though interhemispheric %volume difference did not differ between outcome groups (R: 2.9, 2.4–4.4 IQR; NR: 3.3, 2.8–4.6 IQR; p = 0.71) (Fig. 2B). We did not observe any significant changes in thalamus volume between pre-operative and 1-week post-operative time points in TN patients regardless of side-of-pain or surgical outcome (data not shown).
Intracranial volume as assessed using the v-scaling factor in FSL’s SIENAX tool did not show any significant differences between any groups across all volumetric comparisons (data not shown).
There were significant vertex-wise shape differences seen between the thalami of responders and non-responders (Fig. 3). Non-responders showed significant contralateral thalamus volume reduction compared to responders in an axially-oriented band spanning the outer thalamic circumference made up of two clusters (peak p = 0.019).
Native orientation analysis
There was no pre-operative difference in Cho/Cr between left and right VPM thalamus in HC, RTN, or LTN patients. Overall, across HC and TN patients, there was no difference in mean Cho/Cr (Fig. 4A), nor any difference in %inter-hemispheric Cho/Cr difference between LHC and LTN patients (Fig. 4B).
In HCs, there was a trend towards left greater than right VPM thalalmus NAA/Cr (1.97, 1.88–2.28 IQR and 1.86, 1.63–2.04 IQR respectively; p = 0.060). There was no difference between left and right NAA/Cr in LTN or RTN patients. Left thalamus NAA/Cr was higher in HC compared to RTN patients (p = 0.050). Additionally, NAA/Cr of the left (ipsilateral) VPM thalamus in LTN patients was greater than the left (contralateral) and right (ipsilateral) VPM thalamus in RTN patients (p = 0.029 and p = 0.010 respectively). There were no other between-group differences (Fig. 4C, 4D).
Ipsilateral orientation analysis
There were no differences between pre-operative ipsilateral and contralateral VPM thalamus Cho/Cr in responders or non-responders. However, pre-operative ipsilateral Cho/Cr in non-responders (0.88, 0.78–1.06 IQR) was reduced compared to HCs (1.02, 0.98–1.13 IQR; p = 0.038). There were no other between-group or within-group between-side thalamus Cho/Cr differences (Fig. 5A, 5B).
There were no differences between ipsilateral and contralateral VPM thalamus NAA/Cr in responders or non-responders, and no other between-group or within-group between-side thalamus NAA/Cr differences (Fig. 5C, 5D).
Post-operative metabolite change at 1-week
Pre-operatively, average VPM thalamus Cho/Cr in HCs did not differ compared to pre-operative contralateral Cho/Cr in either responders or non-responders (Fig. 6A). Furthermore, pre-operative contralateral Cho/Cr did not differ between responders and non-responders (p = 0.32). One week after surgery, Cho/Cr in non-responders was significantly lower than in responders (0.83, 0.67–0.97 IQR and 1.04, 0.93–1.17 IQR respectively; p = 0.038) and HCs (p = 0.005), and every non-responder for whom data was available showed a reduction in Cho/Cr irrespective of surgical procedure type (n = 3 MVD and n = 2 BC). Conversely, responders showed no Cho/Cr change with surgery (p = 0.57). (Fig. 6A-C).
Mirroring Cho/Cr, pre-operative average VPM thalamus NAA/Cr in HCs did not differ compared to pre-operative contralateral VPM thalamus NAA/Cr in responders or non-responders (Fig. 6D). Furthermore, pre-operative contralateral VPM thalamus NAA/Cr did not differ between responders and non-responders (p = 0.77). One week after surgery, NAA/Cr in non-responders was significantly lower than in responders (1.94, 1.83–2.41 IQR and 1.59, 1.37–1.79 IQR respectively; p = 0.038) and HCs (p = 0.005), and every non-responder for whom data was available showed a reduction in NAA/Cr irrespective of surgical procedure type (n = 3 MVD and n = 2 BC). Conversely, responders showed no NAA/Cr change with surgery (p = 0.20). (Fig. 6D-F).
In this single-centre, prospective, longitudinal study, we identified several abnormalities of thalamic structure and metabolism in medically-refractory TN patients undergoing surgery. Pre-operatively, TN patients showed increased thalamus volume contralateral to the painful side of the face, confirming earlier retrospective findings . Shape analysis showed characteristic areas of the contralateral thalamus that were larger in responders to surgery compared to non-responders who experienced early pain recurrence. Metabolically, right-sided TN patients showed reduced NAA/Cr concentration in the contralateral left VPM thalamus, but this was not observed for left-sided TN patients. Non-responders to surgery showed significantly reduced pre-operative ipsilateral VPM thalamus Cho/Cr. Following surgery, we found novel evidence of metabolic changes in the VPM thalamus occurring as early as one week after either MVD or BC. These changes—specifically a significant reduction in Cho/Cr and NAA/Cr—were observed only in non-responders, suggesting that surgery for TN has variable effects on thalamic metabolism which may impact long-term pain outcome.
Overall, our patients demonstrated a 74% surgical response rate, in agreement with prior literature, notwithstanding differences in how surgical outcome is measured between different studies . All TN patients were taking antiepileptic medication, and while medication use was largely the same between responders and non-responders, a greater proportion of non-responders were also taking baclofen, perhaps reflecting more exhaustive attempts at medical management. In line with previous reports, non-responders were more likely to be female, younger at the time of surgery, and had TN for nearly twice as long as responders . NVC was identified on pre-operative MRI in 17 of 23 TN patients. At a group-wide level, there was no significant difference in NVC severity between responders and non-responders. However, it is worth noting that 50% of non-responders (3/6) but only 18% of responders (3/17) had no evidence of arterial NVC (i.e., NVC score 0), which may represent a relevant if not statistically significant difference. On reviewing these particular patients in greater detail, there were no obvious clinical or surgical factors that could explain response other than that all 3 non-responders with NVC score 0 were female. Interestingly, patient #23 was the only non-responder with NVC score 3 (i.e., distortion); again, this patient was female, and experienced pain recurrence within one year despite technically successful (i.e., confirmed on post-operative imaging) MVD. Taken together, our data are consistent with the notion that some female patients with a diagnosis of TN—whether in association with true NVC or not—may have a particularly treatment-resistant manifestation of the disease, perhaps explained by a distinct, though as yet unknown, pathophysiology .
Despite the established role of the thalamus in chronic and neuropathic pain , and as a component of the trigeminal sensory system, there have been few in-depth investigations of thalamic structure in TN [18, 19]. We found no whole-thalamus volume differences between HCs and TN patients, aligning with the previous work of Gustin et al. . We did observe left–right volume asymmetry in HCs, which has been observed with many other subcortical structures (e.g., hippocampus), and may reflect normal functional and structural lateralization in the healthy brain. In line with our previous retrospective report , we also observed that the contralateral thalamus was larger across all TN patients, irrespective of the side-of-pain. Accordingly, it would appear that relative side (i.e., ipsilateral/contralateral) is the primary determinant of structural thalamic asymmetry in TN patients, possibly reflecting thalamic enlargement that is the result of sustained hyperactivity in the trigeminal system, similar to enlargement that has been observed in other chronic pain conditions [33, 34]. These data also confirm that the trigeminal system is affected at least as far upstream as the nuclei of third-order neurons residing in the contralateral thalamus. Prior to surgery, our data did not show clear evidence of differences in whole-thalamus volume between responders and non-responders, though more detailed vertex-wise shape analysis revealed a significant, circumferential band of contralateral thalamic volume loss in non-responders compared to responders. Given the small number of non-responders (n = 6), our study was likely underpowered to show statistically significant reductions in whole thalamus volume. However, the robust shape differences we observed suggest that non-responders have a structurally different contralateral thalamus which may play a role in conferring treatment-resistance. Given a reasonable degree of spatial overlap of this circumferential band with the VPM and medial dorsal nuclei, we speculate that volume loss may represent a form of trigeminal system injury—perhaps the result of prolonged chronic TN pain—which is more noticeable in non-responders, in whom it potentially dampens the effect of surgical interventions carried out at more peripheral locations (i.e., at the level of CNV). However, the lack of any significant difference in pre-operative pain severity (measured using the VAS) between responders and non-responders, would suggest that focal thalamic volume loss of this nature does not seem to alter pain relay function in the trigeminal system per se.
Unlike thalamic volume, we did not observe robust evidence of inter-hemipsheric asymmetry in metabolite concentrations of either Cho/Cr or NAA/Cr in the VPM thalamus in HC or TN patients pre-operatively. A trend suggests that NAA/Cr—an indicator of neuronal viability and number —may be elevated in the left thalamus of HCs (p = 0.060), and may be further evidence of normal asymmetry between the left and right thalamus in humans. We did find that NAA/Cr was reduced in the contralateral left VPM thalamus in right-sided TN patients, perhaps reflecting reduced thalamic neuronal integrity that has been shown to be associated with the chronic pain state . However, we did not observe this in left-sided TN patients, perhaps due to the smaller number of LTN patients in our cohort (n = 8). In line with our results, Wang et al.also found reductions in “posterior medial” and “posterior lateral” contralateral thalamus NAA/Cr in TN patients versus HC, and similarly found no difference in Cho/Cr—a marker of membrane turnover which if elevated may indicate a heightened state of cellular proliferation or inflammation—between these groups [21, 36]. Of note, Wang et al. did not limit their analysis to the VPM thalamus, using instead a multi-voxel MRS approach to examine several different thalamic subdivisions, though there is considerable spatial overlap between the VPM as we defined it and their “posterior medial” thalamus.
We found novel metabolic alterations in the thalamus which appear to be implicated in durable response to surgery for TN. First, we observed that non-responders had significantly lower pre-operative Cho/Cr concentration compared to HCs in the VPM thalamus ipsilateral to the side-of-pain. At first glance, this finding seems counterintuitive, since the bulk of trigeminal afferents to the VPM carry sensory information from the contralateral side of the face. That being said, there is neuroanatomical evidence that the smaller, ipsilateral dorsal trigeminothalamic tract containing non-decussating fibers may be implicated in orofacial pain , and recent in vivo tractography results show ipsilateral thalamo-cortical diffusivity abnormalities in TN . Our current observations add to these findings, and further link surgical response to bilateral, system-wide changes in the trigeminal system.
Our most interesting finding is that of very early (1-week) metabolic changes occurring following TN surgery. While thalamus volume remained constant over this time interval, both contralateral Cho/Cr and NAA/Cr showed divergent changes between responders and non-responders: all non-responders had 1-week decreases in both metabolites, while responders maintained stable concentrations post-operatively. We speculate that these findings further suggest—in conjunction with shape analysis results—that there exists a degree of injury to the contralateral thalamus in patients with highly refractory and surgically resistant TN, which prevents it from responding appropriately to upstream surgical interventions.
Our study is limited by a relatively small sample size of 23 TN patients (19 in MRS analysis) and 20 HCs, and our findings will need to be replicated in larger TN datasets. However, our sample size is comparable to other prospective MRI-based studies of the thalamus in TN [18, 19, 21]. Another possible limitation is the heterogeneity of the TN group, which included patients who underwent different types of surgical procedures (MVD and BC), and in some cases repeat surgery. That being said, we did not observe any difference in thalamic volume or metabolite concentrations between patients treated with different surgical approaches, or undergoing non-virgin surgical treatment, suggesting that the central role of the thalamus in treatment responsiveness—or resistance—may be independent of interventions carried out more peripherally in the trigeminal system. Furthermore, while group-level medication-class use was largely the same between responders and non-responders, we did not have access to data on exact medication dosage and duration of use—both of which could have influenced the thalamic structural and metabolic abnormalities we observed—and could not correct for these in our statistical analyses. Finally, we arbitrarily defined responders as patients who continued to have satisfactory pain relief at one year following surgery, though it is certainly possible that some of these patients could have gone on to have significant pain recurrence at more delayed follow-up.
Our findings confirm that trigeminal system abnormalities exist in TN patients as far upstream as the thalamus, evidenced by structural and metabolic alterations primarily—though not exclusively—in the thalamus contralateral to the side-of-pain. TN patients who respond inadequately to surgery exhibit baseline differences in thalamic shape, and differing trajectories of early post-operative change in thalamic metabolism, compared to responders. We conclude that the thalamus has a critical role to play in the pathophysiology of TN and its response to surgical treatment. The clinical implications of this finding at the individual subject level are an important topic for further research.
Availability of data and materials
Data available on request due to privacy/ethical restrictions. Please contact corresponding author Dr. Tejas Sankar (firstname.lastname@example.org) to request data.
Trigeminal nerve (i.e., cranial nerve V)
Root entry zone;
Magnetic resonance imaging
Diffusion tensor imaging
Ventral posteromedial thalamus
Magnetization-prepared rapid acquisition gradient echo
1H-magnetic resonance spectroscopy
Balloon compression rhizotomy
Barrow neurological institute
Visual analogue pain score
Headache Classification Committee of the International Headache Society (IHS) The International Classification of Headache Disorders, 3rd edition. Cephalalgia. 2018;38(1):1–211. https://doi.org/10.1177/0333102417738202.
Zakrzewska JM, Akram H. Neurosurgical interventions for the treatment of classical trigeminal neuralgia. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2011;9:1–46. https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD007312.
Burchiel KIMJ, Clarke H, Haglund M, Loeser J. Long-term efficacy of microvascular decompression in trigeminal neuralgia. J Neurosurg. 1988;69:35–8.
Leal PRL, Barbeir C, Hermier M, Souza MA, Cristino-Filho G, Sindou M. Atrophic changes in the trigeminal nerves of patients with trigeminal neuralgia due to neurovascular compression and their association with the severity of compression and clinical outcomes. J Neurosurg. 2014;120(June):1484–95. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpa.2002.12.001.
Leal PRL, Amedee Roch J, Hermier M, Souza MAN, Cristino-Filho G, Sindou M. Structural abnormalities of the trigeminal root revealed by diffusion tensor imaging in patients with trigeminal neuralgia caused by neurovascular compression: A prospective, double-blind, controlled study. Pain. 2011;152(10):2357–64. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pain.2011.06.029.
Guclu B, Sindou M, Meyronet D, Streichenberger N, Simon E, Mertens P. Cranial nerve vascular compression syndromes of the trigeminal, facial and vago-glossopharyngeal nerves: Comparative anatomical study of the central myelin portion and transitional zone; Correlations with incidences of corresponding hyperactive dysfunctio. Acta Neurochir (Wien). 2011;153(12):2365–75. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00701-011-1168-1.
Devor M, Govrin-Lippmann R, Rappaport ZH. Mechanism of trigeminal neuralgia: an ultrastructural analysis of trigeminal root specimens obtained during microvascular decompression surgery. J Neurosurg. 2002;96(3):532–43. https://doi.org/10.3171/jns.2002.96.3.0532.
Liu Y, Li J, Butzkueven H, et al. Microstructural abnormalities in the trigeminal nerves of patients with trigeminal neuralgia revealed by multiple diffusion metrics. Eur J Radiol. 2013;82(5):783–6. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejrad.2012.11.027.
Desouza DD, Hodaie M, Davis KD. Abnormal trigeminal nerve microstructure and brain white matter in idiopathic trigeminal neuralgia. Pain. 2014;155(1):37–44. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pain.2013.08.029.
Leal PRL, Roch J, Hermier M, Berthezene Y, Sindou M. Diffusion tensor imaging abnormalities of the trigeminal nerve root in patients with classical trigeminal neuralgia: a pre- and postoperative comparative study 4 years after microvascular decompression. Acta Neurochir (Wien). 2019;161(7):1415–25. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00701-019-03913-5.
Hung PSP, Chen DQ, Davis KD, Zhong J, Hodaie M. Predicting pain relief: Use of pre-surgical trigeminal nerve diffusion metrics in trigeminal neuralgia. NeuroImage Clin. 2017;15(January):710–8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nicl.2017.06.017.
Tohyama S, Hung PS, Zhong J, Hodaie M. Early postsurgical diffusivity metrics for prognostication of long-term pain relief after Gamma Knife radiosurgery for trigeminal neuralgia. J Neurosurg. 2018;131(August):539–48. https://doi.org/10.3171/2018.3.JNS172936.
Zhang H, Lei D, You C, Mao BY, Wu B, Fang Y. The long-term outcome predictors of pure microvascular decompression for primary trigeminal neuralgia. World Neurosurg. 2013;79(5–6):756–62. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wneu.2012.01.040.
Holste K, Chan AY, Rolston JD, Englot DJ. Pain Outcomes Following Microvascular Decompression for Drug-Resistant Trigeminal Neuralgia: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Neurosurgery. 2019;86(2):182–90. https://doi.org/10.1093/neuros/nyz075.
Willsey MS, Collins KL, Conrad EC, Chubb HA, Patil PG. Diffusion tensor imaging reveals microstructural differences between subtypes of trigeminal neuralgia. J Neurosurg. 2020;133(2):573–9. https://doi.org/10.3171/2019.4.JNS19299.
Tohyama S, Hung PSP, Cheng JC, et al. Trigeminal neuralgia associated with a solitary pontine lesion: clinical and neuroimaging definition of a new syndrome. Pain. 2020;161(5):916–25. https://doi.org/10.1097/j.pain.0000000000001777.
Vartiainen N, Perchet C, Magnin M, et al. Thalamic pain: Anatomical and physiological indices of prediction. Brain. 2016;139(3):708–22. https://doi.org/10.1093/brain/awv389.
Rutland JW, Huang K-H, Gill CM, et al. First application of 7-T ultra–high field diffusion tensor imaging to detect altered microstructure of thalamic-somatosensory anatomy in trigeminal neuralgia. J Neurosurg. Published online 2019:1–9. doi:https://doi.org/10.3171/2019.6.jns19541
Gustin SM, Peck CC, Wilcox SL, Nash PG, Murray GM, Henderson LA. Different pain, different brain: thalamic anatomy in neuropathic and non-neuropathic chronic pain syndromes. J Neurosci. 2011;31(16):5956–64. https://doi.org/10.1523/JNEUROSCI.5980-10.2011.
Gu T, Ma X-X, Xu Y-H, Xiu J-J, Li C-F. Metabolite concentration ratios in thalami of patients with migraine and trigeminal neuralgia measured with 1H-MRS. Neurol Res. 2008;30(3):229–33. https://doi.org/10.1179/016164107X235473.
Wang Y, Li D, Bao F, et al. Thalamic metabolic alterations with cognitive dysfunction in idiopathic trigeminal neuralgia: A multivoxel spectroscopy study. Neuroradiology. 2014;56(8):685–93. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00234-014-1376-5.
Danyluk H, Lee EK, Wong S, et al. Hippocampal and trigeminal nerve volume predict outcome of surgical treatment for trigeminal neuralgia. Cephalalgia. 2020;40(6):586–96. https://doi.org/10.1177/0333102419877659.
Sindou M, Leston J, Decullier E, Chapuis F. Microvascular decompression for primary trigeminal neuralgia: Long-term effectiveness and prognostic factors in a series of 362 consecutive patients with clear-cut neurovascular conflicts who underwent pure decompression. J Neurosurg. 2007;107(6):1144–53. https://doi.org/10.3171/JNS-07/12/1144.
Han PP, Shetter AG, Smith KA, et al. Gamma Knife radiosurgery for trigeminal neuralgia: Experience at the Barrow Neurological Institute. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2000;47:1013–9. https://doi.org/10.1159/000029771.
Smith SM, Jenkinson M, Woolrich MW, et al. Advances in functional and structural MR image analysis and implementation as FSL. Neuroimage. 2004;23(S1):208–19.
Smith SM, Zhang Y, Jenkinson M, et al. Accurate, robust and automated longitudinal and cross-sectional brain change analysis. Neuroimage. 2002;17(1):479–89.
Jenkinson M, Beckmann CF, Behrens TEJ, Woolrich MW, Smith SM. FSL Neuroimage. 2012;62(2):782–90. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2011.09.015.
Patenaude B, Smith SM, Kennedy D, Jenkinson M. A Bayesian Model of Shape and Appearance for Subcortical Brain. Neuroimage. 2011;56(3):907–22. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2011.02.046.
Provencher SW. Automatic quantitation of localized in vivo 1H spectra with LCModel. NMR Biomed. 2001;14(4):260–4. https://doi.org/10.1002/nbm.698.
Schaltenbrand G, Wahren W, Hassler RG. Atlas for Stereotaxy of the Human Brain. 2d, rev. a ed. Stuttgart: Thieme; 1977.
Heinskou TB, Rochat P, Maarbjerg S, et al. Prognostic factors for outcome of microvascular decompression in trigeminal neuralgia: A prospective systematic study using independent assessors. Cephalalgia. 2019;39(2):197–208. https://doi.org/10.1177/0333102418783294.
Magown P, Ko AL, Burchiel KJ. The Spectrum of Trigeminal Neuralgia Without Neurovascular Compression. Neurosurgery. 2019;85(43):553–9. https://doi.org/10.1093/neuros/nyz0481.
Hashmi JA, Baliki MN, Huang L, et al. Shape shifting pain: Chronification of back pain shifts brain representation from nociceptive to emotional circuits. Brain. 2013;136(9):2751–68. https://doi.org/10.1093/brain/awt211.
Schmidt-Wilcke T, Leinisch E, Gänßbauer S, et al. Affective components and intensity of pain correlate with structural differences in gray matter in chronic back pain patients. Pain. 2006;125(1–2):89–97. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pain.2006.05.004.
Moffett JR, Ross B, Arun P, Madhavarao CN, Namboodiri AMA. N-Acetylaspartate in the CNS: From neurodiagnostics to neurobiology. Prog Neurobiol. 2007;81(2):89–131. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pneurobio.2006.12.003.
Tayebati SK, Amenta F. Choline-containing phospholipids: Relevance to brain functional pathways. Clin Chem Lab Med. 2013;51(3):513–21. https://doi.org/10.1515/cclm-2012-0559.
Henssen DJHA, Kurt E, Kozicz T, van Dongen R, Bartels RHMA, van Cappellen van Walsum AM. New insights in trigeminal anatomy: a double orofacial tract for nociceptive input. Front Neuroanat. 2016;10(5):1–14. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnana.2016.00053
University of Alberta Hospital Foundation Sankar Research Establishment Grant, Edmonton Civic Employees Charitable Assistance Fund, Charles H. Backman Fund (TS). No funding bodies were involved in: the design of the study, the collection, analysis, and interpretation of data, or in writing the manuscript.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This study was approved by the institutional human research ethics board at the University of Alberta (Protocol #00067116). All patients from whom data was included in this manuscript provided written informed and ongoing consent. Administrative/operational approval was provided by Alberta Health Services (Health Information Act Research Agreement #81929).
Consent for publication
All study participants willingly consented to the use of their information for dissemination and publication.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary Figure S1: 1H-MRS chemical shift image (CSI) slab placement and ventral posteromedial (VPM) thalamus voxel selection. CSI slab placement is shown in mid-sagittal (A), coronal (B), and axial (C) views, overlaid on T1-weighted MPRAGE images. Bilateral VPM thalamus voxel (indicated in yellow) is shown in coronal (B) and axial (C) views.
About this article
Cite this article
Danyluk, H., Andrews, J., Kesarwani, R. et al. The thalamus in trigeminal neuralgia: structural and metabolic abnormalities, and influence on surgical response. BMC Neurol 21, 290 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12883-021-02323-4
- Microvascular decompression
- Percutaneous rhizotomy